- Ren
- Pilgrim
- From: Austin, Tx
- Registered: 2001-07-29
- Posts: 14959
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
because some people can't be original enough to come up with their own monsters and copy Tolkein consistently...Dwarves, Elves, Orcs, Hobbits, Goblins etc...
Part of why i get bored to death of D&D...
"You know, if you ate more comfort food you'd probably kill less people" - Hurley, Lost
- SeanS
- Pilgrim
- Registered: 2004-03-29
- Posts: 62
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Like Tolkien's other races, orcs have their roots in Norse mythology. Also, you really can't copyright ideas--just specific works.
- ceywren
- Pilgrim
- From: hole in the bottom of the sea
- Registered: 2004-02-28
- Posts: 18790
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
makes sense. thanks SS :)
was just curious cuz i have no idea how copyright works.
"It's not that it's such a mystery This new-found malaise. It's just that this mystery Has taken your place."
-Gordon Downie, Mystery-
- Tad
- Hierarch
- From: California
- Registered: 2001-05-30
- Posts: 6981
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
"Orc" is an old word for unpleasant creatures -- out of Old English, I think, but I can't remember for certain -- and therefore only different from "fairy" or "troll" because less defined.
In other news, I have missed jury duty. I'm in trouble. I completely spaced it. So I may be updating this from jail.
I'm going to call now, so I'll let you know what they said. Start those file-cakes a-bakin'...
"God bless your crooked little heart." - Tom Waits
- ceywren
- Pilgrim
- From: hole in the bottom of the sea
- Registered: 2004-02-28
- Posts: 18790
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
thanks tad :)
and don't worry, i'm sure they'll let you have a laptop in your cell after a bunch of impatient smarchers swarm them.
eta: hmmm. there seems to be some reference as to a sea monster called an orc but otherwise everything that pops up is tolkien or dnd related. bah. stupid internet.
[ January 09, 2006: Message edited by: Ceywren ]
"It's not that it's such a mystery This new-found malaise. It's just that this mystery Has taken your place."
-Gordon Downie, Mystery-
- The Microphone
- Pilgrim
- From: The End of Time
- Registered: 2002-02-25
- Posts: 3958
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Tolkien uses the words "orc," "goblin" and "hobgoblin" interchangeably, and goblins were definitely "bad people" in norse mythology. I'm suprised Jotunn (giants) didn't show up...
For a dollar you could find a girl of every possible design, But you couldn't find a decent man, or a word spoken kind.~Rum Brave, Murder By Death Microphobe's Art Space || The Downwright's Arena
- Kuno
- Pilgrim
- From: Eindhoven, Netherlands
- Registered: 2003-04-01
- Posts: 2686
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Orc:
Orc (sometimes spelled Ork) comes from the Latin word Orcus, a title of the god Pluto, the king of the underworld. It was later used to refer to the underworld itself. The word appears later in the Germanic languages without its Latin ending, in the more familiar form of "Orc". It was then revived by J. R. R. Tolkien in his fictional stories of Middle-earth as the name of a race of creatures that are often used by evil forces as soldiers.
Link to the full article (for what it's worth).
Seems like it was some kind of sea monster before Tolkien made orcs what they are now.
Edit for spelling.
[ January 09, 2006: Message edited by: Kunohara ]
There's a beginning, two middles, and an end. - Firsfron of Ronchester
- ceywren
- Pilgrim
- From: hole in the bottom of the sea
- Registered: 2004-02-28
- Posts: 18790
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
note to self: remember that encyclopedias exist :/
thanks for the link kuno!
"It's not that it's such a mystery This new-found malaise. It's just that this mystery Has taken your place."
-Gordon Downie, Mystery-
- bumadax
- Pilgrim
- Registered: 2001-06-11
- Posts: 9734
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
just tell the jailers they're all part of a virtual reality program, then make a break for it while they scratch their heads.
smile at people
- ArcticSwan360
- Pilgrim
- From: Minnesota
- Registered: 2004-11-06
- Posts: 1075
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
I was just generalizing when I said orcs. I really don't know what type of creatures I will have in my fantasy world. I was just showing there will be a variety.
http://thewritersguild.spaces.live.com/I'd greatly appreciate comments on my blog. It will be about reading, writing, gaming, movies, tv and more. Thank You, and rember: Join Today! The Guild Needs You!
- Ren
- Pilgrim
- From: Austin, Tx
- Registered: 2001-07-29
- Posts: 14959
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
You know what I'd liek to see in fantasy creatures? Some really bizzare stuff... stuff not based on modern mythologies or faerie-tales. Something not based on stereo-typed angry mobs...I'd like to see a race of creatrus that walk on their hands and talk out their butts...oh wait those are politicians...Thats why I like hard-core sci-fi where the Aliens are truly alien, tri-lateral symmetry, octahedral symmetry...puddles of sentient goo, hyper-sentient shaded of blue... Gimme some originality! Hrm...maybe I should work on that myself...
"You know, if you ate more comfort food you'd probably kill less people" - Hurley, Lost
- Stuart
- Pilgrim
- From: Yorkshire
- Registered: 2002-07-08
- Posts: 3736
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
That's fine to say but you still use familiar terms of reference to describe aliens, hands, butt, and politicians.
Most stories rely on the belief of the reader in the basic motivations of the characters involved; I suspect truly alien behaviour probably wouldn't make for a good story.
...- --- - . / .-.. .. .-.. -.-- !
- Ren
- Pilgrim
- From: Austin, Tx
- Registered: 2001-07-29
- Posts: 14959
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Possibly but it might be a good excercise to try...*ponders*
"You know, if you ate more comfort food you'd probably kill less people" - Hurley, Lost
- Stuart
- Pilgrim
- From: Yorkshire
- Registered: 2002-07-08
- Posts: 3736
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
There's a good sequence in Peter Hamilton's latest novel (Pandora's Star/Judas Unchained) when the alien Prime experiences two humans for the first time and is utterly confused by their behaviour as it "investigates" them thoroughly to see how they work.
Truly alien behavious would be, well, alien.
...- --- - . / .-.. .. .-.. -.-- !
- Ren
- Pilgrim
- From: Austin, Tx
- Registered: 2001-07-29
- Posts: 14959
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Timothy Zahn wrote an interesting trilogy about a first encounter situation that goe horribly awry due to miscommunication errors...turns out the aliens communicated through the dead spirits of their ancestors, but the radio waves from Human radio technology were killing the spirits so the initial attempt at first contact looked to the aliens like an attack on their ancestors..,the first book was written from the humn perspective, the second from the aliens and the third was split between them. It took me until about halfway through the book to relaize what was goign on...very cleverly crafted...
"You know, if you ate more comfort food you'd probably kill less people" - Hurley, Lost
- Jaime
- Pilgrim
- From: Wilmington, NC
- Registered: 2001-06-01
- Posts: 11441
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Tad: while they technically *could* toss your butt in jail for playing hooky, they'll likely just issue you a new jury duty summons in the next couple months.
But if not, hey, it's a day or two of uninterrupted writing time! And a hefty fine...
Yield to temptation; it may not pass your way again.
-- Heinlein
- Jaime
- Pilgrim
- From: Wilmington, NC
- Registered: 2001-06-01
- Posts: 11441
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Stuart wrote:There's a good sequence in Peter Hamilton's latest novel (Pandora's Star/Judas Unchained) when the alien Prime experiences two humans for the first time and is utterly confused by their behaviour as it "investigates" them thoroughly to see how they work.
Eeek. That part very nearly squicked me - and I'm not very squickable.
I woulda liked the first book a LOT more if every single female (with one exception) wasn't a nymphomaniac bimbo, even the intelligent ones. He writes his women like a 30something whose sex drive is still in college.
Yield to temptation; it may not pass your way again.
-- Heinlein
- Ren
- Pilgrim
- From: Austin, Tx
- Registered: 2001-07-29
- Posts: 14959
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Haime wrote:He writes his women like a 30something whose sex drive is still in college.
...hey I resemble that statement...er wait thats a bad thing innit?...*sigh*
Someday I will grow up...but until then madness ensues...8)
"You know, if you ate more comfort food you'd probably kill less people" - Hurley, Lost
- Aan`allein
- Hierarch
- From: The Netherlands - occasionally
- Registered: 2001-06-04
- Posts: 5636
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Stuart wrote:I suspect truly alien behaviour probably wouldn't make for a good story.
The Gods Themselves.
Also, most current day hard science fiction authors have done at least a couple of short stories with pretty alien perspectives (no humans involved at all). The one I best remember at this point are some by Baxter in his collection Phase Space. Life does look pretty different when you're an energy fluctuation in the first few microseconds of the lifetime of the expanding universe. :)
[ January 11, 2006: Message edited by: Aan allein ]
Mozilla developer comment of the however long it'll be this time: <Mossop> run for the hills! <Boriss> i can't, i'm at a local maximum!Just Imagine...
- Stuart
- Pilgrim
- From: Yorkshire
- Registered: 2002-07-08
- Posts: 3736
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Haime wrote:
Eeek. That part very nearly squicked me - and I'm not very squickable.
I woulda liked the first book a LOT more if every single female (with one exception) wasn't a nymphomaniac bimbo, even the intelligent ones. He writes his women like a 30something whose sex drive is still in college.
I'm trying to think who the exception was, Doi?
I'm struggling to answer your latter point without showing myslef up for the stereotype that I am, which for a 12 and a bit year old 30something is precocious with no intentional irony.
...- --- - . / .-.. .. .-.. -.-- !
- Meike
- Pilgrim
- From: Maintal (Germany)
- Registered: 2004-10-11
- Posts: 143
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
@Tad
do you like to get the articel from "Frankfurter Rundschau"? I asked you at page 10 in this blog?
:-(
Meike
°°~~~°° Home is where dogs and teddies are °°~~~°°
- Tad
- Hierarch
- From: California
- Registered: 2001-05-30
- Posts: 6981
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Sorry, Meike. It's been busy and I've been stupefied.
I will almost certainly get the article from my German publisher. If it were a review, I'd be happy to have a brief synopsis from you, since my German's still not good enough to make total sense out of reviews, but since it's an interview with me, I'm so bored with my own voice that I don't feel a powerful need to read it in ANY language.
But thank you for noticing it, and if you run across anything else interesting, I'm always grateful to know.
"God bless your crooked little heart." - Tom Waits
- Kuno
- Pilgrim
- From: Eindhoven, Netherlands
- Registered: 2003-04-01
- Posts: 2686
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Stuart wrote:There's a good sequence in Peter Hamilton's latest novel (Pandora's Star/Judas Unchained) when the alien Prime experiences two humans for the first time and is utterly confused by their behaviour as it "investigates" them thoroughly to see how they work.
Exactly the example I would give.
Haime wrote:Eeek. That part very nearly squicked me - and I'm not very squickable.
Yup, but I liked it because of that. It means it was very well written.
Edit: Oh, wait, the / thingie closes something.
[ January 12, 2006: Message edited by: Kunohara ]
There's a beginning, two middles, and an end. - Firsfron of Ronchester
- ArcticSwan360
- Pilgrim
- From: Minnesota
- Registered: 2004-11-06
- Posts: 1075
- Website
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
Tad, I'm not sure if you saw, but I posted a reply to your asking to be more specific. It's on the tenth page. Also, have you seen either of these two Studio Ghibli films: A Whisper of a Heart, or The Cat Returns?
I'm just wondering because of your novel, Tailchaser's Song.
http://thewritersguild.spaces.live.com/I'd greatly appreciate comments on my blog. It will be about reading, writing, gaming, movies, tv and more. Thank You, and rember: Join Today! The Guild Needs You!
- Ren
- Pilgrim
- From: Austin, Tx
- Registered: 2001-07-29
- Posts: 14959
Re: DOGBLOG: Beyond Poodledome.
that reminds me I need to check TMC's schedule for tonights studio Ghibli Films...last week had two movies I've already seen...waiting to see "Porco Rosso"
"You know, if you ate more comfort food you'd probably kill less people" - Hurley, Lost
|
|
|
|
|